If gentle parenting isn’t working for you, or you want to learn how to create healthy discipline for your kids, child psychologist Dr. Kat Green has evidence-based strategies for how parents can effectively get their kids to listen, especially children with challenging temperaments.
Dr. Green and I explore practical techniques to improve communication, reduce power struggles, and build stronger parent-child relationships. We also discuss effective parenting strategies that focus on structured discipline, managing anxiety, and fostering cooperation through evidence-based methods. You’ll get practical tips for reducing chaos, increasing compliance, and supporting children’s emotional regulation.
Note: The following is the raw transcript of my conversation with Dr. Kat Green.
Options for When Gentle Parenting Fails
Emma McAdam (00:00)
So if you’re like me, parenting is one of the absolutely most important things that you do, but it’s also one of the most anxiety provoking. Like it’s something that has a lot of uncertainty and can be really challenging to figure out what’s the right way to make something happen. And so today I’ve invited one of my absolute favorite psychologists, Dr. Kat Green. She’s a board certified child psychologist and she is coming to teach evidence-based skills for how to get your kid to listen to you.
Now what you’re going to hear in this interview is quite different from a lot of the common parenting advice. And I can see the perspective of gentle parenting, but I think it’s gone too far to the point where parents are now so worried about correcting or having a consequence connected to a behavior that kids are being harmed by not having clear enough boundaries. And so…
Today, Kat Green’s gonna teach us her four-step system for how to get a kid to listen to you. And I found this conversation fascinating. I love talking with Kat. She’s amazing. And I’m really excited to share it with you, because I feel like it’s so important and so helpful for our kids, both for their self-esteem and for our sanity and for our community and our home wellness. So let’s jump in. Let’s go.
Skills for How to Get Your Kid to Listen to You
Emma McAdam (01:18)
Dr. Green, thank you so much for being here. Really excited for you to share with our audience all of your wisdom.
Kat Green (01:23)
Yeah, I’m happy to be back.
Emma McAdam (01:26)
So, okay, I attended a training of yours like five years ago that was on how to get your kid to listen to you. Well, it was actually on evidence-based parenting techniques that show effectiveness. That’s really what it was. And this one little 15-minute segment has completely changed how I parent and improved how I parent like immensely. So that’s why I invited you here today to be the star of the show.
Kat Green (01:49)
Awesome that it stuck.
Emma McAdam (01:50)
Yeah. So could you please teach our audience how can you get your kids to listen to you? Like if you need them to do a chore or you need them to stop doing something that’s dangerous or inappropriate or in general, you just need them to listen. Yeah. To get stuff done.
Kat Green (02:03)
And to do stuff. Yeah.
Emma McAdam (02:07)
Yeah.
Kat Green (02:07)
Yeah, so I’m happy to talk through that and kind of understanding it does work best in kind of a sequence of other skills put together. So actually, I have a separate course that is trying to put those together on Teachable that will have the link on how to parent preschoolers with big emotions.
Because really that tends to be where I live is the truth is with pretty easygoing, calm kids, they probably do do stuff. Like it’s probably sort of the, hey, I need you to do it. And it might have to remind, but it doesn’t escalate to where you’re feeling super frustrated and they’re frustrated and there’s just lots of tears. So that’s kind of my, my wheelhouse is absolutely is effective with kids who are easygoing, but it’s particularly studied and effective with kids with harder temperaments, bigger emotions, faster emotions, harder time switching between tasks. And that’s really, some of this might differ from, it does differ from a lot of what we find on social media and in the world right now. And again, a lot of stuff works with kids that are easygoing, but we do have to be more precise. And we actually know a lot about what helps kids with bigger or more intense emotions.
How I start most things, first you’re a good parent, like helping people understand you are doing amazing things. Like, please understand parenting is so hard. It’s so hard.
Emma McAdam (03:36)
Yeah, seriously, it’s the hardest thing I’ve ever done. I’m a licensed therapist. spent a decade working with youth in treatment centers. Like I thought I had these skills. I start parenting and I’m like, wow, this is probably the most confusing, uncertain, anxiety provoking, important thing I’ve ever done. And I don’t feel like I’m doing a good job at it. Like it’s seriously hard. Yeah.
Kat Green (03:56)
Yes, it is so hard. to be honest, no parent really feels like they’re doing well. And this is one of the interesting things that’s come up in the social media realm. And we hear all the time, like you’re only seeing people’s highlights, but I don’t know that we always translate that to that parenting side to say like, that is not the vast majority of parents feel like they just got it together all the time. Most parents, I think it’s like a core of parenting that you just always feel like you don’t really know what you’re doing and you’re really just hoping for the best. But
Emma McAdam (04:27)
Yeah. Yeah.
Kat Green (04:29)
I hope this specific strategy can provide kind of some direction in giving instructions, giving commands. You’ll see this, so in different evidence-based literatures, it has different names. I use the very creative term effective commands, I know. I have a medal for creativity, but that’s what’s really common
Emma McAdam (04:48)
you
Kat Green (04:48)
in different manuals. They’ll call it effective commands or giving commands. So yeah, I’m going to jump in, but just know that there are other strategies you can pair with them if your kid has a more difficult temperament that can make it more effective.
Emma McAdam (05:00)
Yeah, I think that’s important to recognize because like, mean, my audience is going to know me from my anxiety teaching and it’s not like I have a single anxiety hack that solves anxiety. It’s like, no, I taught a 31 part course. It’s like, here’s
Kat Green (05:13)
Yes.
Emma McAdam (05:14)
like kind of this web of like stuff that helps and works. And with parenting, like we can’t isolate a single skill. Like it’s all part of this, this bigger ecosystem, but this skill I consider very pivotal, like very important.
Beyond Gentle Parenting: Core Behavioral Skills That Work
Kat Green (05:27)
I love it. And I will say, parenting is incredibly complex, but especially in the like the preschooler version. And I mean, we add skills as kids get older, but there’s really four core skills that we
Emma McAdam (05:40)
I like this.
Kat Green (05:41)
…. work with and we manipulate and we work together. And obviously then applying them takes lots of nuance and things like that. But that’s one of the things that’s actually very, very doable.
Emma McAdam (05:51)
Hmm.
Kat Green (05:53)
to learn the skill and the content, will say applying it is what takes the rest of your life. I will say.
Emma McAdam (05:57)
What are the four skills? I’ve got to know!
Kat Green (05:59)
Yeah, so I mean, when we start in any of these courses, we start with something called the child directed interaction. But on the parent side, I see it as a parent laboratory. That makes me sound kind of mad scientist-esque.
But it’s incredibly effective that way. Parents become very aware of the language and the approaches that they’re using. And then I think my fundamental, anytime people are stuck in an elevator with me and make the mistake of asking what I do, or anytime I’m asked to go invited to lecture anywhere, I typically will talk about this core skill of differential attention, which is kind of that second piece and then effective commands builds on that.
And then that last skill, we’re typically talking about kind of how to use effective strategies for aggression. So using time out in ways that are actually very research supported and effective, safe, right? And great for kids and families. And then as they get older, we talk about how to use rewards and things like that. it’s it’s a fairly concentrated group of skills. And then it just takes a lot of practice from that
Emma McAdam (06:59)
Perfect.
Kat Green (06:59)
point.
Emma McAdam (07:00)
Fascinating. Fascinating. Okay. Yeah. Let’s go.
Effective Parenting Commands: When to Give a Command
How do you, how to give effective
Kat Green (07:04)
Okay, well,
Emma McAdam (07:05)
commands?
Kat Green (07:06)
Jumping in with effective commands. So there’s two parts to effective commands. And I think we often jump to the consequences. What do I do if they don’t do it? Hold that thought. We’re going to get there. But what a lot of parents don’t realize is just the way kids are built, we can get a lot of mileage out of the way we set the command up.
We live in a frenetic busy, chaotic life and environment. And we often set instructions and commands up for kids in ways that are kind of minimizing the chances that they will follow through. the
Emma McAdam (07:42)
Yeah.
Kat Green (07:42)
first, really the first part of effective commands is how we initiate that sequence. as you practice this skill, you’ll actually also get a little bit more discriminating in, is this actually a command I need them to do?
Or is this just like something I want them to do, but it is not worth it to me to consequence. if you think to yourself, yes, I want them to go get that spoon for me. If it is not worth going through a consequence sequence, make it a favor, not a command, right? Like once you initiate a command, then you’re committing to, okay, there’s going to be a consequence at the end of this. So some of this, as you practice, you’ll go, actually, I’m just going to give a lot fewer commands and I’m going to
Emma McAdam (08:23)
Yeah.
Kat Green (08:23)
help differentiate. So you’re able to get the best response to the specific things you do need done. Okay, yeah, go ahead.
Emma McAdam (08:29)
Yeah, that’s a good piece of clarification because what we’re talking about here is something you need your child to do versus something you’d like your child to do or you’d want your child to learn or you’d encourage them to improve on or something like that. And so like there is room in relationships for requests.
Kat Green (08:50)
Absolutely.
Emma McAdam (08:51)
And like with adults, we teach this all the time. Like you can make requests of people, like, could you please talk to me differently? But that’s not a boundary. So there’s like, there’s a time for a request and a time for a boundary. And like with adults, it’s like, well, you know, if there’s an if then statement, then it’s a boundary. And
Kat Green (09:07)
Yeah.
Emma McAdam (09:08)
if you’re, if you’re unwilling to do an if then statement, it’s not a boundary, it’s a request.
Gentle Parenting Fail: Kids are Not Undersized Adults
Kat Green (09:12)
So I love that you’re tackling that parallel to adults because particularly in Western culture, and I realize your audience is everywhere, so I think being attentive to whatever the cultural norms are where you’re at, but in Western culture, we’ve increasingly started approaching kids like they’re little adults.
But I think it’s not fair to kids and it’s not fair to parents because they do not have adult brains. And I know you talk a lot about this in your channel and write about understanding the brain and all these different functions, but kids have kid brains. It’s remarkable, but they
Emma McAdam (09:46)
Yeah. Yeah.
Kat Green (09:47)
- So increasingly we’re seeing societal pressure in this cultural shift to treating kids like adults. And that
Emma McAdam (09:54)
you
Kat Green (09:54)
doesn’t actually help them develop the skills that they need to be adults later. And
Emma McAdam (09:59)
Yeah, yeah.
Kat Green (10:00)
In fact, I think we even see from a cultural standpoint, some vilifying people that don’t treat their kids like adults. To say, you’re not letting them grow their foot. And that science just doesn’t support that.
Emma McAdam (10:13)
So, and yeah, no, and to be specific, like I found myself as a therapist and being immersed in therapy culture, not as a trained child psychologist with all the research behind it, but like this idea of like, could I just talk to my kids and ask them nicely and explain it to them and then tell them like if they don’t do it like don’t you see that like harms my trust in you and like you what I was doing is I was trying to treat them like a little adult who had this relational bank account with me and that they would think about and empathize with my needs which kids don’t have that skill and that they would consider these relational topics and kids are concrete thinkers not abstract thinkers and kids would just care about like how their actions would impact the future and kids can’t do that yet either and so I was using all of these like soft parenting skills with my young kids and it literally left them confused. Like they were confused, they felt guilty, they thought they were bad. I was like, felt guilty and I thought I was bad. But what we weren’t getting was like clarity. They didn’t actually understand what I was asking them. And so as people listen to your presentation, they might be like, but what about everything I’ve heard that says consequences are so shaming or like what about like how isolated and harsh this is?
And the reality is like I have over the last decade have come to the understanding that like we’ve gone too far on the gentle parenting side of things to the point where it’s hurting our kids because we’re asking them to understand why they should do the dishes instead of just helping them learn to do the dishes you know
Kat Green (11:56)
Also, the dishes don’t get done and everyone’s frustrated. So then it just increases negative emotion, it escalates everything because
Emma McAdam (12:02)
Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Kat Green (12:03)
it feels like there’s not a right way to do it.
Emma McAdam (12:06)
That’s right, that’s right, yeah. And I mean, there’s a lot of cultural factors here, but that also is inclusive of like, parents have less kids these days, so they are able to like spend hours and hours and hours with one kid, like trying to convince them to do something. But when you have a bigger family or more kids or a school environment or a group environment, like we actually do need compliance and co-working and getting along to be part of…like healthy community. it’s important to our society that not every single kid gets accommodated completely to all their personal needs. sometimes kids just need to learn, like, a skill of like, when I’m asked to do something, I will, like, I will stand up and do it.
Kat Green (12:47)
What’s interesting is, again, sometimes we see that sort vilified, but all of our data show that that’s a really important and healthy skill for kids.
Emma McAdam (12:57)
Yeah.
Kat Green (12:58)
If you’re asked to do something you don’t have the capacity to do, it doesn’t feel good. It doesn’t feel like, look at all the autonomy I have.
You may not recognize you don’t have the capacity to do it, right? Like kids don’t necessarily recognize it, but being in an environment, I think a lot of adults can empathize with being in an environment where some person or some culture constantly wanted them to do something they couldn’t do. And what we see is setting up this structure, helping kids get better at following instructions. It builds a sense of what we call self-efficacy. The idea that like, I can do stuff. A lot of the kids I work with come in going, I’m just bad at following instructions.
I don’t know what it is, but I’m just bad at it. And I’m working primarily with parents because of that. It doesn’t help me to do one-on-one with an eight-year-old to be like, Johnny, if you followed instructions, you’d be less stressful. And he’s probably
Emma McAdam (13:52)
Ha!
Kat Green (13:53)
like, yeah, I know. It’s not a problem with knowing it. It’s a problem with doing it. So
Emma McAdam (13:57)
Yeah.
How to Get Your Kid to Listen to You on the First Try
Kat Green (13:57)
this is what we’re trying to do in parent-focused work is narrow the gap between knowing what they need to do and doing what they know.
Right, so a lot of what we
Emma McAdam (14:06)
Yeah.
Kat Green (14:07)
do as adults is clear the runway. We’re trying to say, how do I make it the most accessible for you to follow this instruction? Right, and we’re doing this, I’m trying to think of all the things we’ve kind of talked through. If we come back to deciding what you need them to do, that this is an instruction. Once you’ve decided that, your primary goal as the parent is to say, how do I set this up for success? How do I clear the runway in their brain? There’s lots of competing things. We know that kids brains, like they’re smaller, they’re smoother, they’re less developed, but they’re also less efficient, right? So it’s a lot easier for things to interrupt, to interfere with what they’re trying to do. So we’re going
Emma McAdam (14:50)
Mm-hmm.
Kat Green (14:50)
to try to clear that runway. So the big thing in front of them is I just got to take off, right? Like I
That’s my runway. Here’s what I’m trying to do. So when we do this, the first thing I ask parents to do is get a thousand percent of their kids attention. Calling
Emma McAdam (15:06)
Yes.
Kat Green (15:08)
from the other room, right? Because what we’re trying to do is set it up to not have to repeat commands. Because what typically happens is I initially say, how often does your kiddo follow what you ask him to do? Comply with directions. And again, I work with kids that, you know, have harder temperaments, bigger emotions. So it’ll be like, well, they do comply like 50 % of time. like, how often are they complying on the first time? And the parent’s like, oh, for real? No, they don’t. Right? Like, that’s not a thing.
Emma McAdam (15:37)
Yeah. Yeah.
Kat Green (15:38)
That’s the goal we’re trying to. We’re trying to reduce the number of repetitions, which is going to keep everyone regulated a little bit more, particularly the parent. Kid might still fly off the handle initially.
Emma McAdam (15:48)
Yeah, yeah.
Kat Green (15:49)
But as a parent, you know that when you feel that sense of dread, right? When they don’t do it and you’re like, oh, you guys gear up for battle. And it’s like, okay, here we go, it’s game time.
Emma McAdam (15:58)
Mm-hmm.
Kat Green (16:01)
That’s what we’re trying to avoid.
Effective Parenting Commands: Get Your Kid’s Attention
Kat Green
So the first thing we’re gonna do is setting up, say, okay, is this actually something I need to get done? All right, need them to do. And it might be for a period of time, you don’t ask them to do things that you’re like, no, they really should be doing it based on their age. But if they’re not, start small and kind of work up to the shoulds, add those pieces on as they gain momentum and self-efficacy to say like, I can follow instructions. Look at me follow instructions. Rock star. So a thousand percent of their attention. Being in the same room, will often, depending on the age and the child, I’ll like touch their shoulder, right? I always use Johnny as my, invisible made up child. But you know, touching their shoulder and saying, Johnny, great job looking at me.
So you can also start with praise right from the beginning when they look at you and you know that they’re processing. Cause otherwise you’re like, I don’t know if they’re deliberately ignoring me. I don’t know if they’re just spacing out. don’t know. Like, let’s just address that question. If you don’t know, let’s go get their attention. if they’re in the middle of something, you pause it, right? Say, all right. And then you’re ready to, you know, I typically will start with their name.
Effective Parenting Commands: Stop Asking, Start Stating
Kat Green
And then you’re giving them a command in a short, as short as you can, as little discussion as you can. And I want you to really watch for questions instead of statements. So along the line of how we interact with adults, we tend, when we’re trying to be nice, ask questions to kids when we don’t really mean them as questions. If you need an adult to do something for you, you likely will ask it as a question.
Hey, can you bring me my shoes? Right? And you’re,
Emma McAdam (17:42)
Yeah. Mm-hmm. Yeah. Would you do the laundry?
Kat Green (17:47)
yeah, will you do the laundry? So it’s the can you, could use, will you, would use that are almost always how these questions slash commands start. The challenges for kids when we remember their kid brains, kids are in this middle, I’m a super nerd about like language development, because it’s just like astounding to me.
But as you look at kids that are developing these language skills, one of their brain’s jobs is to say, what does that certain intonation mean? And what is the inherent punctuation there? what do I do in response to a question? And for kids, they’ve gotten real good at whatever language there is their primary language. And if it’s a question, their brain goes, I know what to do with this one. I answer it. Bam, nailed it.
Right? So like, it’s like, hey, Johnny, can you get your shoes? Yes. Right? And the brain’s like, woo, I answered it. And here’s
Emma McAdam (18:37)
Yes, that is the answer. I can get my shoes. Interesting.
Kat Green (18:41)
the challenge. Is the brain then shuts it down? Right? The brain’s like, I did the thing. I answered the question.
Emma McAdam (18:44)
Ha, ha. Interesting.
Kat Green (18:48)
And it shoves it off to archive. And then you come in and Johnny’s like in his underwear playing with Legos. And you’re like, hey, you told me to get your shoes on. And he’s like, I have no memory of that.
Emma McAdam (18:58)
This is like my child. Yeah. Yeah.
Kat Green (18:58)
Because in his brain, he did the thing. He answered the question. And I realized a lot of parents were like, okay, but he knew. we could get in the weeds about what percentage they knew versus not. It’s just not helpful.
Emma McAdam (19:09)
Yeah, it simply
Kat Green (19:10)
it just doesn’t matter. So the older they get, sure, I absolutely think sometimes kids answer the question knowing full well you meant it as a command and they’re not do it. Like, sure. But the strategy works anyway.
So instead, especially with youngers, their brain’s like, I did the thing. I answered the question, done. And it’s like, is gone from their existence. So getting their attention and then making it a statement, not a question. So if you find yourself asking a question, just take a second to rephrase it as a statement. I tend to start with, I need you to, because it’s really hard for my brain not to ask, can you, could you, will you, would yous?
So if I start with, hey, I need you to, it helps my brain make that a statement.
Effective Parenting Commands: Say What TO DO Instead of What Not To Do
Kat Green
The other piece is then I need you to blank. I want to tell them what they need their body to do, not what they need to stop or not do. So instead of, I need you to stop jumping, again, we’re trying to clear the runway. In Johnny’s head,
Not jumping could mean a lot of things, right? That are not walking on his feet to the door, right? Not …
Emma McAdam (20:20)
Right, right.
Kat Green (20:21)
jumping could be, mean, somersaulting is not jumping, skipping, walking backwards, laying on the ground. All of those things are not jumping. And
Emma McAdam (20:26)
Lipping. Yeah, yeah. That’s true. Yeah.
Kat Green (20:31)
instead of making him do the mental work of sorting through going, this one, probably not. Maybe this one. Ooh, look at her face. Not that one. Like instead of making him sort through that, just tell him what his body needs to do, right?
Emma McAdam (20:45)
Mm-hmm.
Kat Green (20:46)
I need you to put your pockets on the chair, right? Like that’s give it as straight and as clear as you can what you want his body to do. And again, I all the time find myself saying stop blank, whatever it is, stop doing this, stop getting in my space. Like that’s fine. It’s not like a horrible parent award. You just go, okay, wait, what do I actually need him to do?
And you go, okay, I need you to give me space. The nice thing about this for younger ones, if we’re talking about what you need them to stop, it usually falls into a category of I need you to give me space, right? I need you to follow instructions or I need you to, I would say giving space is the biggest. Keep your hands to yourself, right? I need you to use a calm voice.
Emma McAdam (21:31)
Yeah. Mm-hmm.
Kat Green (21:34)
You’ll find that as you’re practicing this, there’s probably a handful of commands that you’re like, these are my go-tos. I need you to blank. Repetition is fantastic. People are like, how do I make it more creative? Like, no, just tell them, hey, I need you to give me space. It’s way easier for him if he has a bucket of this goal he keeps doing. It’s going to make him stronger and stronger at it until it’s like, thanks for being three feet away.
Oh, thanks for not touching me. Oh, thanks for instead it’s like, hey, thanks for giving me space or whatever it is. So
Emma McAdam (22:04)
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Okay.
Kat Green (22:06)
getting 1000 % of their attention, setting up as a statement, not a question, and telling them what to do instead of what to stop or what not to do. Questions, thoughts so far?
Emma McAdam (22:19)
Yeah, so I think the attention one’s really important because it’s so easy for me to be in the kitchen and be like, hey, hey,
Kat Green (22:26)
Hehehehehe
Emma McAdam (22:27)
child number two, you need to do your chore.
Kat Green (22:28)
Ha ha ha.
Emma McAdam (22:29)
Let’s go. And she will be reading a book or whatever she’s doing and literally does not hear me. So I’m like, hey, hey. And she still doesn’t hear me. I’m like, hey. And then I go over there.
Child number two, why aren’t you doing your chore? Like you know what you need to be doing. And it’s easy to get quite escalated in just the attention gaining stage.
Kat Green (22:53)
Yes.
Emma McAdam (22:54)
Like, why don’t you listen to me the first time I ask? And it’s like, I did not even register that you were
Kat Green (22:58)
Exactly.
Emma McAdam (22:59)
there. So it’s like, I walk over there, put my hand on her shoulder. Hey there, child number, I say her name. I say her name, I’m just not saying it for the internet. And I get her eye contact, I get on her level, I put my hand in front of her book pages. I like the TV is off for sure. We only do TVs on like half of Friday and Saturday. So normally that’s not the issue, but turn off the TV or pause the TV and then do it and that prevents the first 90 % of repeating myself. Like that’s what I found. Yeah.
Kat Green (23:29)
Yes, absolutely.
And it’s even, it prevents that escalation on the parent side. And there’s something even, maybe I’m just a petty person, but when I’ve asked them a thousand times and then I go over and they’re not like, they’re cool as a cucumber, cause they didn’t even know I
Emma McAdam (23:43)
Yeah!
Kat Green (23:43)
was there. That makes me more annoyed that I’m like, why are you like, right? That’s exactly. So I think
Emma McAdam (23:46)
yeah, don’t you care about me? Don’t you know?
Kat Green (23:50)
it addresses, I love like the 90 % of the attention gaining that kind of escalation piece.
Smart Parenting: Transitional Warning for Task Switching
Kat Green
One other kind of element I’ll add is what we call a transitional warning. sort of a transitional heads up because it warning
Emma McAdam (24:02)
Yeah, yeah.
Kat Green (24:03)
has this like negative connotation to it. What we’re really trying to do is you think about their brain, they got a million things going on for adults. It takes maybe one to two seconds to start, start shifting our attention for kids. can take up to five seconds. This will, we’ll come back to this later, but
It can take much longer. just not as efficient. They’re having to work with less efficient networks to switch something over. For kids that have more intense emotions, transitions are almost always challenging.
Emma McAdam (24:33)
Why is that? Like, what is that?
Kat Green (24:35)
So if we think about it, doesn’t take much to kind of elevate their nervous system a little bit, right? So they tend to be more,
Emma McAdam (24:42)
Like their nervous system is more sensitive.
Kat Green (24:44)
it’s more sensitive, they’re more kind of zero to 60. And there’s a lot of things, part of it depends on what kind of big emotions we’re talking about in the context of like ADHD, right? Their brain is not naturally giving them the organizational pieces to say, okay, here’s about how much time you have and then you’ll do this and then we…
We talk about something called time blindness is a very well known and established feature in ADHD. It’s also true for kids though, separate from ADHD, because it’s developmental. So if you ever asked your kid like, was that so fun? And they’re like, yeah, we only got to do it for two minutes. And you’re like, we’ve been at the park for an hour.
Emma McAdam (25:18)
Yeah.
Kat Green (25:19)
If it’s something fun, it’s never long enough. And it’s something boring, you’re like, it only took you two minutes. And they’re like, took forever. Like they
Emma McAdam (25:26)
Yeah, yeah.
Kat Green (25:27)
don’t have the capacity to assess time.
So we often see that more intense emotion, that sensitive system interact with things like that. So all of a sudden they feel blindsided, right? By like, but it hasn’t been 10 minutes. And you’re like, yeah, it’s definitely been 30 minutes. So it’s that regulatory element. Their brain’s not doing some of the legwork to help temper that switch to kind of smooth things over.
So when we give a transitional heads up, a transitional warning, I do not do a countdown. That tends to make kids really frustrated. So I don’t say like, hey, in 10 minutes, okay, in eight minutes, seven minutes, you’re still not ready, five minutes. And I realize, I mean, I say, I don’t, I’m sure I do sometimes. I try not to, right? In an ideal effective world that likely is gonna escalate them without
Emma McAdam (26:14)
which yeah.
Kat Green (26:17)
actually increasing the chances of getting it done. And it tends to escalate parents because they’re like, I gave you a hundred warnings.
So instead, what I tend to do is I recommend parents give one five-ish minute. If we’re talking preschool, they don’t know minutes. It doesn’t really matter. But something in the realm, I’ll say one minute, I don’t have to set a timer. As kids get older, you have to be a little more accurate. But so for example, if I can use your child number two, so you go in, hand on the book, all right, child number two, in three minutes, it’s gonna be time for chores.
What I love about that is that’s all you do. You have nothing else you need to do in that you didn’t give a command, you didn’t… So if child number two says, okay, you can say, hey, thanks for listening. It’s an opportunity to praise and say, yep, that was beautiful. Or if they
Emma McAdam (27:07)
We got it, thanks, we’re on a team here.
Kat Green (27:09)
go, but three minutes isn’t enough time to finish the… And I’m sorry to child number two, they probably don’t look like that, but…
Emma McAdam (27:15)
No, they probably do.
Kat Green (27:15)
Everyone can say like, I know what we’re talking about. When they say you pause the show, you pause the switch, whatever it is, you say, all right, in three minutes, it’s time to blank.
When they go into full, whoa, my life is so hard. You just walk away. You don’t need to explain why we do it. You don’t need to remind them, hey, we talked about this. Nope. A transitional warning. Literally all you’re doing is getting their attention. You’re giving their brain some information to start shifting gears of what to expect.
And I expect some of the time they will lose their mind. And it’s okay. And you walk away, you walk
Emma McAdam (27:48)
I like this. I like this. Yeah.
Kat Green (27:50)
away because it’s not time to initiate the command sequence yet. And then when it sounds like I’m like going into space, initiating the command thing, but that’s exactly what we’re doing. Right? Like then when I go back, I also have in my mind, okay, this is the state I’m walking into, which might help me prepare to be a little more precise in giving effective commands. then I come back.
Right, if I’ve paused the TV till Johnny in three minutes, it will be time to get your shoes on. He’s like, my life, alas, is so hard. No one else has to do it. All of the things. You just turn the TV back on and leave. He can either finish watching or melt. Like, okay.
Emma McAdam (28:27)
Yeah. Yeah.
Kat Green (28:28)
Then you come back when it’s time. You pause or turn off the TV and say, all right, it’s time to get shoes on or I need you to get your shoes on. So that’s all that brings us all the way up through to our setup point.
Any other questions thoughts.
Emma McAdam (28:43)
No, I just love that and I’ve noticed that the transition, what’d call it? Transitional announcement? What was it? Heads up.
Kat Green (28:48)
Transitional heads up. I call it a transitional warning, but like I said, I’ve started to shift that language a little bit because I’m not actually warning them. Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
Directive Parenting to Avoid Power Struggles
Emma McAdam (28:55)
You’re not like threatening them, yeah. No, I just noticed that especially like with the TV to never do that like while the TV’s running. If I’m like, hey guys, we’re turning off the TV in five minutes. They literally do not hear me. They do not hear me. So I walk over there, pause the TV. how much is left on this show? Four minutes? Okay. In four minutes when this show’s over, we’re turning it off. Then we’re gonna do our bedtime routine. Okay? Y’all agree?
If people, if they don’t agree, then maybe this is bad of me. It’s like, no, we need to watch more. Then I’ll be like, you have a choice. You can either watch four more minutes of your show or we can turn it off now. Either one’s fine. Is that too mean of me?
Kat Green (29:32)
Oh, don’t, it’s funny. I don’t use, I don’t view that as mean at all. I probably wouldn’t because you’re having to invest more. it, yeah, I think it probably,
Emma McAdam (29:39)
Yeah, it’s like a power struggle, that’s what I actually meant. Is that me engaging in a power struggle?
Kat Green (29:43)
it probably increases the opportunities for a power struggle.
Emma McAdam (29:47)
Yeah.
Kat Green (29:47)
when it’s just a transition, I wouldn’t ask it as a question or ask for their agreement in the moment. And again, we’re talking about kids, we’re talking about before puberty, younger kids, asking them to decide something. I can tell you as a grown adult, when I know it’s time to turn off my show and go to bed, if I asked myself, do you want to do that right now? Do you agree? I think a pretty substantial part of myself would be like, no. So we’re just trying to decrease the cognitive
Emma McAdam (30:15)
No, yeah. Okay.
Kat Green (30:17)
…. load. I think that could be effective and the truth is with any of these, if you have something that works, don’t change it.
Emma McAdam (30:23)
Yeah, sure.
Kat Green (30:24)
If you’re like, yeah, that usually isn’t a fight, then I would keep doing it. If you came to me and said, this is the biggest fight of the night, then I would say, all right, as soon as you make that announcement, you’re out of there. Yeah. Yep.
Emma McAdam (30:33)
Just get out of there. Just avoid the power struggle by saying, is what we’re doing. You can have your show back. See you in four minutes. Like, you’re just being more directive as a parent instead of more collaborative.
Kat Green (30:42)
more direct and you’re just giving less opportunity for those emotions to kind of hike up. But again, if
Emma McAdam (30:46)
Yeah.
Kat Green (30:47)
it isn’t a major concern, like then I think it’s fine. That’s the thing is I’m not like,
Emma McAdam (30:50)
Okay, interesting. Okay. Yeah.
Kat Green (30:53)
you know, if it were something you’re like, this is really hard for me. And then especially if it was with your older kids, if you’re like, okay, my three year old, my four year old, whatever,
Separating Correction from Teaching in Evidence-Based Parenting
Kat Green
But I’ve got a 10-year-old that like, it’s not appropriate for them to lose their mind when I give them a transitional warning. In that case, I’d say, okay, in the moment, I want you to do the same thing.
But then have a conversation out of the moment to say, all right, what can we do differently? And that’s when you combine it with skills and other things. So it’s not that you
Emma McAdam (31:18)
Yeah, yeah.
Kat Green (31:19)
never address it if you’re like, I just don’t think this is acceptable.
Emma McAdam (31:23)
Mm-hmm.
Kat Green (31:23)
But in the moment, nothing will be learned. is no learning happening.
Emma McAdam (31:26)
This is, yeah, this is like, I love this point and I wanna highlight it so much because I found this especially with my oldest child who’s very sensitive, tends to take things like very personally and intensely, that like if I give her a little correction or there’s a blow up or there’s a problem in the moment or I see her do something with her friends and I’m like, my gosh, that is like so rude. Like instead of me calling her out in that moment and being like, why are you doing this? Like that’s so rude. Like I can’t believe you’re treating your sister that way.
I try to think back down my pyramid of like parenting foundations and it’s like have I actually listened to her and taught her like how to do this the right way and in that moment of correction it never works it always feels like shame to her it always feels like correction and punishment like why are you talking to your friends that way didn’t you know a nicer way to talk to your friends is like this it like never works so I like note that down I have a notes folder on my phone I’m like stuff to teach child number one it’s like
how to like correct your friend politely and then like three days later I’ll be like hey Leah how can we have a little chat about about like what do do if you need to correct your friend but you don’t want to hurt their feelings so then I make it like a like a gentle teaching collaborative moment
Kat Green (32:41)
Yeah!
Emma McAdam (32:42)
instead of like in this moment of conflict I’m gonna correct you and shame you into changing anyway this is like I feel like the key I have discovered for my sensitive kid of like, I can teach so much better two days later.
Kat Green (32:57)
I love the things to teach kids, kid number one note. that’s,
Emma McAdam (33:02)
Yeah.
Kat Green (33:03)
that’s cause I like try to store it away mentally. And then
Emma McAdam (33:05)
Yeah.
Kat Green (33:06)
the next time I see it, I’m like, oh yeah, I didn’t teach that thing. So I love that.
Emma McAdam (33:09)
Yeah, it shows up again.
Kat Green (33:10)
It also helps parents. gives it a place to go. Cause as parents, when you see something that could potentially hurt them in their life, we have a sense of urgency because you’re a good attentive, warm parents. You’re like, I gotta help her fix this. And so
Emma McAdam (33:22)
Yeah, you don’t… Mm-hmm.
Kat Green (33:24)
I love it. A note or something like that. actually, use this in a lot of other strategies. Give it a place to live so that you are able to kind of put that down, but then can come back to it in effective way. I love that. That’s fantastic.
Emma McAdam (33:38)
Yeah, because as a parent, you want to be able to correct and help and teach your kid. But I think as parents, we often get frustrated that when we try to teach our kid, they’re very resistant to us. And that’s because
Kat Green (33:47)
Yes.
Emma McAdam (33:48)
we try to pair correction and teaching at the same time. And I found like separating those like, hey, I just like notice how you’re talking right now. And then like three days later, be like, OK, like, let’s.
Kat Green (34:01)
Yeah, and then you give kind of the step-by-step skill.
Emma McAdam (34:03)
Yeah, just like let’s let’s actually do some education here. But.
Kat Green (34:05)
Yeah, I love it.
Emma McAdam (34:07)
That is not what we’re talking about, because that is not a command. That’s not like a directive. This is just like my parenting, like one thing I’ve learned.
Kat Green (34:12)
It could be, but yeah.
Emma McAdam (34:14)
It can be related to like, how do we turn off TV when it’s time to do bedtime routine? Like, how do we make this a good thing? Because I want you to have TV, but it’s not working out for me when everyone screams. So
Kat Green (34:27)
Yes.
Emma McAdam (34:27)
what can we do together? Like, how can you get used to this? Do you want a visual timer? Do you want like something more clear? Do you need…
Kat Green (34:36)
And what I talk a lot about in working with kids, it’s yes, I like giving choices as kids get a little bit older,
Emma McAdam (34:42)
Mm-hmm.
Kat Green (34:43)
but always using bounded choices. So when we give
Emma McAdam (34:45)
Yeah.
Kat Green (34:46)
them open-ended choices to like, how would you like me to transition you? That’s
Emma McAdam (34:51)
Ugh.
Kat Green (34:51)
actually an enormously open question. So instead, I will propose like a bounded choice to say, would you like me to come in at five minutes or three minutes?
Emma McAdam (35:02)
Mm-hmm.
Kat Green (35:03)
Or would you like a visual timer? Or I don’t know what the alternative would be, but I think giving one choice that’s quite narrow instead of this iterative. Here’s a bunch of things that might help.
Emma McAdam (35:15)
that’s a good idea.
Kat Green (35:16)
so if it’s something that you’re like, okay, this is something I need those commands to go smoother. You come back and teach it in the moment, operating in bounded choices. They’re not questions. They’re not as open ended. And it’s never about whether or not they need to do the thing.
Emma McAdam (35:31)
They still have to do the thing.
Kat Green (35:31)
Because I just don’t think it’s fair. I don’t think it’s fair to ask kids if they want to do the thing that we need them to do. I think it’s a false question. And it makes kids feel like they need to want to do the thing.
Emma McAdam (35:44)
Right.
Kat Green (35:44)
I do a lot of things I don’t want to do. I don’t need to want to do the thing, right, to do it. So.
Emma McAdam (35:52)
And I want to be clear, this is a developmental stage, not how you’re going to treat this kid for the rest of their life.
Kat Green (36:00)
Yeah, of course.
Emma McAdam (36:01)
Like, we’re talking concrete thinkers before 10 or 14 years old, probably prior to 14 for sure,
Kat Green (36:08)
Yeah.
Emma McAdam (36:09)
Right? As they grow into teenagers, we probably aren’t going to use the same command sequence except for in emergencies, right? Is that fair?
Kat Green (36:18)
Well, I think we’re using similar principles. Again, we’re trying to clear the clutter. We’re trying
Emma McAdam (36:21)
Yeah. Yeah.
Kat Green (36:23)
to clear and say, how do I reduce the load from your brain to make it more likely for you to be successful in following this command? And even if you don’t want to do it, because it’s really important
Emma McAdam (36:33)
Yeah, that’s true.
Kat Green (36:34)
as a life skill to do things you’re not jazzed about. And instead
Emma McAdam (36:39)
Mm-hmm. Yeah.
Kat Green (36:40)
to stay regulated, we’re kind of acclimating them to like, yeah, sometimes I have to do stuff that isn’t my favorite thing to do, especially for teens, right? They’re like, yeah, I don’t like taking the garbage out. Sometimes I have to take care of my house, even though I don’t really want to. Yeah, that’s like a great skill. It can become routine so it doesn’t escalate them. So when they’re… living on their own, have to take out the garbage, it’s not like, right, their brain,
Emma McAdam (37:03)
Yeah.
Kat Green (37:04)
their brain just goes, okay, I’m not gonna, I’m not gonna send out a panic alarm about that. That’s easy,
Emma McAdam (37:08)
Yeah,
Kat Green (37:09)
you’ve done that.
Emma McAdam (37:10)
I’m just gonna do it.
Parenting Boundaries that Balance Warmth and Firmness
Emma McAdam
So developmentally, being more directive when they’re younger is really important as parents. And I think a lot of modern parenting is telling parents not to be so directive, but I think it’s really important for kids’ development.
Kat Green (37:24)
Well, and I think it’s an important clarification that you can be very warm while you give a direct command. think we,
Emma McAdam (37:29)
Yeah.
Kat Green (37:32)
I think some of the, danger of the new language around being gentle or being like, it implies that anything that’s not that is harsh, there are also unhelpful ways to give commands, right? So using harsh language, belittling them, using names, those can all be.
It can be like, well, I’m being directive. Like, no, there are unhelpful or damaging ways to give commands, those are in the extremes, right? There’s this very clear, supportive, directive giving a command that you can do in a very warm way. But what it does is it helps build like really solid relationships. Parents become predictable to kids, which feels safe, right? Predictable
Emma McAdam (38:10)
Yeah, yeah, yes, absolutely.
Kat Green (38:14)
in healthy and safe ways, they’re going, parent is doing the appropriate boundary setting and choosing, and they’re setting me up to do this one piece of it that’s developmentally appropriate for me, and it can
Emma McAdam (38:26)
Yeah.
Kat Green (38:26)
create a really positive relationship.
Emma McAdam (38:28)
Yeah, I just have to back this up. There’s this narrative out there that being, being soft and gentle is always the most loving thing you can do for child and being directive or firm or even giving consequences is harmful. And it’s not that at all. Like I think having boundaries and limits and expectations is one of the most loving things we can do. And we can do it in a connecting way.
And I’ve seen this with my kids where I’ve been like imposing a consequence. I’ve been applying a consequence that they have merited and they
Kat Green (38:55)
Thank
Emma McAdam (38:56)
are very sad about this
Kat Green (38:58)
Mm-hmm.
Emma McAdam (38:58)
and They come to me for comfort and I can be like
Kat Green (39:01)
Yeah.
Emma McAdam (39:01)
I know I’m sad too. I feel you I can see you’re sad and we are like connected against like the problem Instead of against each other like it doesn’t have
Kat Green (39:11)
Yeah!
Emma McAdam (39:11)
to be one or the other Like I’ve just seen so many times with my kids where I can be connected with them and be like and you’re getting a consequence and I have this expectation that you follow through on what you said you would do or you go to soccer practice even though you’ve decided you hate soccer forever, doesn’t matter. like we have a family rule, once you commit to a sport, you do it for three months and then you can quit, you know? And then they cry and I’m like, I know, it’s hard. I’m with you.
Kat Green (39:35)
Yeah.
Emma McAdam (39:36)
And we’re still going.
Kat Green (39:37)
I think you just, mean, especially where you do so much in the anxiety realm, right? We think about uncertainty
Emma McAdam (39:43)
Mm-hmm.
Kat Green (39:44)
as a primary driver of emotional arousal, right? Like uncertainty
Emma McAdam (39:47)
mmm bread
Kat Green (39:48)
is a primary driver of feeling anxious or irritable or upset. And what, again, what you’re doing as a parent by, when I say clearing the runway, you’re providing this structure that reduces uncertainty. In the moment, they’re not like, thank you for reducing my uncertainty, but.
Emma McAdam (40:04)
Yeah.
Kat Green (40:05)
We’re reducing the overall uncertainty and chaos that’s in their mind
Emma McAdam (40:09)
Yeah.
Kat Green (40:09)
to the point that it helps them develop kind of healthy regulation skills.
Emma McAdam (40:13)
This is so important and I’ve seen this with my anxious kid. have one of my kids is extra extra anxious. She gets it from me, I guess. But she was very, very sensitive and anxious. And the more I tried to accommodate and be soft and sweet and talk with her through it and help her choose on her own to do the right thing. She was just more and more anxious. And when I started being like, here’s Kat’s process, step one, two, three, four, and we’re getting to step four, which is if then, right? I’m gonna give you a consequence
Kat Green (40:39)
Yep.
Emma McAdam (40:40)
if you don’t do the thing.
Kat Green (40:41)
Yep.
Emma McAdam (40:42)
Then her anxiety literally decreased when I added in more structure and what people might consider more harshness. Her anxiety literally decreased because it was no longer, will you be nice to mommy and do what you’re supposed to do? It’s like, hey, do the thing or you don’t get TV tomorrow. Okay.
Kat Green (41:00)
You’re just reducing the messaging to her brain that this is an emergency that everyone needs to attend to. It’s just providing it’s cutting through that, cutting to the structure. So I love that.
Emma McAdam (41:10)
Okay, so the first one is get 1000 % of their attention, then do a command, not a request. Is that the
Kat Green (41:15)
Mm-hmm.
Emma McAdam (41:16)
second one? Third one, or is that the third one?
Kat Green (41:18)
Probably. No, that’s, it depends on where you put a transitional warning. This is always the problem with my…
Emma McAdam (41:22)
Transitional warning. 100% of their attention. Command, not a request. Or statement, a statement. I need you to,
Kat Green (41:26)
Yep. A statement.
Emma McAdam (41:30)
I need you to put your shoes on and get in the car. Okay? Did
Kat Green (41:34)
Yep. Yep.
Emma McAdam (41:36)
I miss one thing? What’s the next? Okay.
Kat Green (41:38)
No, we, no, so at this point we’ve set up the command If you do like getting your shoes on and getting the car, if you find that they’re not doing both of those, split them up. So again,
Emma McAdam (41:48)
that’s right. That’s right.
Kat Green (41:50)
if they are, then it doesn’t matter. if you’ve got something that’s working and it’s positive and not harmful, like yeah, just keep doing it. But if like—
Holding Boundaries for Your Kids: 5 Seconds and If-Then
Emma McAdam (41:56)
Kat, no kid ever just got their shoes on and got in the car. That has never happened. It has literally never happened. So I
Kat Green (41:59)
That’s a great point. I wasn’t gonna say that, but you know.
Emma McAdam (42:04)
need you to get your shoes on and then I’ll connect with you.
Kat Green (42:06)
I need you to get your shoes on and then you can follow through. Okay. Now, you have likely set yourself up for much more success. And if at any point in that you realize you missed a step, assuming the house is not actually on fire, take five seconds and say, okay, wait, What do I need them to do here? Right? If they’re just still not doing it.
Worst thing that happen is five seconds later, they’re still not doing it. So take the time, try to fight that sense of urgency to repeat yourself and set the command up. So now we’re going to start into our if then sequence. So as you give this command, like, I realize this is oversimplification, but I find that to be helpful. After you give the commands, I recommend parents have two options and only two. Okay.
You are gonna sit there and say, alright Johnny, I need you to get your shoes on. And you’re gonna wait five seconds, and I know this probably isn’t good for the internet, but I’m gonna demonstrate because it feels like an eternity, right? If I say, Johnny, I need you to get your shoes on.
It feels like forever. If you did that to a partner or another adult at work, we expect a response within one and a half to two seconds before it gets weird, right? That we’re like, kids are less efficient. So you have to like give it that long period of time. Okay. So in this five second wait, you’re not going to repeat yourself. You’re not going to explain why you’re not all of those words. You’re just going to bottle them up and you’re gonna sit there looking neutral and you can either praise anything that looks like compliance. So if he’s like, my life is so hard, but he flops onto the ground towards the shoes, I’m gonna say, all right, inch in towards our shoes. I’ve completely,
Emma McAdam (43:46)
Ha
Kat Green (43:47)
I’m not giving any attention to the weeping and wailing and gnashing of teeth, but I’m on, I’m narrating or I’m putting a spotlight on what he is doing as a way to tell his brain, yep, this is it, this is it right here to make it stronger over time.
So either you’re giving attention to anything that looks like compliance or you’re just sitting there waiting. Looking neutral, you kind of go into a robot parent mode. I will tell you during my five seconds, I’m sitting there going, okay, what’s my consequence gonna be? I’m just trying to think what’s my if then here. So at the end of five seconds, if you see nothing towards compliance, then you’re gonna restate it one time in the form of an if-then or a when-then, depending on the context.
So the structure is not the hard part. It’s hard to practice. The hard part is coming up with thens. It’s coming up with natural, immediate consequences that you can use that can either be positive or they can be a loss of privilege. But it’s coming up with things that are effective and it takes a lot of trial and error. So the example I give in my course.
If I’m working with parents, I still have the kid in the therapy room, but they’re just doing their thing. I have them there so we can coach and practice things that we need to. So at the end of the session, they have to clean up the toys if they want to get a sticker. So there are a number of kids that couldn’t care less about stickers, and this is how we find that out. So I would say, all right, I get down.
I have given him a transitional warning because we’re almost done wrapping up session. I touch his shoulder, I get his eye contact, I all right, Johnny, it’s time to clean up. And if it’s a preschooler, I’m going to start cleaning up. I’m just going to start, da da da da, just totally neutral. If there’s anything that looks like compliance, I’m like, at you in there. This is so fast. This and that, it’s fantastic. He gets on the way out, like, you cleaned up. So you get a sticker. He goes out the door. Everything’s fantastic. Again, in my therapy office, that’s a mixed bag. So instead, after five seconds, I got nothing and I’m helping coach parent, because all parent wants to do is, Johnny, Johnny, Johnny, you need to clean. This is disrespectful. We’re in public. Like this is embarrassed.
Emma McAdam (45:55)
Come on, come on, come on, come on. Yeah.
Kat Green (45:58)
these. I’m like. Doesn’t even faze me right where a parent might get down. They start helping me clean up after five seconds. I’m going to stop. I’m going to give him eye contact and say, all right, Johnny, if you help clean up, you will get a sticker.
This can go a lot of different ways. Sometimes it’s like, blah. And then they start cleaning up and I’ve just got the spotlight on the actual physical movement of cleaning up. He gets a sticker at the end. We don’t say next time do it the first, nope. We just pretend like it happened the first time. He gets the sticker, goes out on his merry way.
Parenting Solutions for Meltdowns and Resistance
Kat Green
The other is Johnny, if you clean up, you will get a sticker. I even care about stickers. Stickers are stupid. Okay, here’s the thing.
He may or may not care about the sticker, but instead of engaging with that, I’m gonna wait another five seconds. So after I’ve given the if-then, I’m gonna wait another five seconds. I keep cleaning up, right? He’s either refusing, melting or not. If he does anything that’s cleaning up, I snap my attention back, we’re good to go. He gets the sticker and goes, if he doesn’t, I coach the parent and say, all right. So he didn’t clean up. He’s not gonna get a sticker. I put him up on my table, right? Parent.
Escorts him like if they again we’re working with littler kids, so they pick them up They’re walking them out and I it’s possible. He doesn’t care about the sticker, but I’m gonna resist the urge to say okay Well, then if you clean up you can do this or okay if you clean up you can do it instead I gave the option and if he really doesn’t care he leaves and he’s like forget it stickers are stupid Then
Emma McAdam (47:25)
Yeah.
Kat Green (47:25)
next time I’m not gonna use a sticker next time he comes. I’m gonna say alright. Here’s the deal if you help clean up
we can play a game of, Uno or you can turn off the light or you can hit the elevator button on the way out. So the next time I will offer a different option, but I’m not going to do it in the moment. I’m not going to scramble on
Emma McAdam (47:42)
Okay.
Kat Green (47:42)
my heels, desperately trying to find another consequence that will work. Because
Emma McAdam (47:47)
Mm-hmm.
Kat Green (47:47)
here’s the thing, they’re learning if thens over 10,000 iterations. They’re learning
Emma McAdam (47:52)
Right, right.
Kat Green (47:53)
it over, practicing it over and over and over again. So here’s the thing. If it didn’t work, it looks exactly like it does normally, right? But he learned that there wasn’t if then and it did happen. So there’s still learning that happens. doesn’t bother me if he says, forget you, I don’t care. The other option is he says, I don’t even care about stickers, they’re stupid. And then it’s time to go. And the parent has that face on there, you know, that look on their face. So this is like, I can’t believe you did this to me because they know Johnny cares about the sticker. And I say, okay.
So he didn’t clean up, doesn’t get the sticker this time. Here’s the only comment I want after it is to say like, maybe next time. So when you pick him up, he’s going to lose it. And this is where we have other strategies. I don’t just set people off, know, throw them to the wolves, but it’s like, not that our children are wolves, but sometimes, right?
Emma McAdam (48:42)
It feels like it.
Kat Green (48:44)
So they, pick them up or they’re walking them out and he’s like, sticker. didn’t get a sticker. I’m
the parents gonna try to say it’s okay next time and say no we’re gonna ignore we’re not gonna give attention to the melting but I would just look for another opportunity if you get in by yourself if you get into your car seat by yourself you can pick the radio station right or you can look or as soon as they’re calmer then you can introduce distraction you can introduce like we’re gonna do this and if he comes back to a Dr. Green is so mean and the parents thinking yeah but out loud it’s just gonna ignore
And as soon as he’s back, focused on something else, we’re not going back to rehash, right? There’s, it’s just content for different videos some other day, but we have to be really careful about rehashing things that happened in the past, especially with Littles. So
Emma McAdam (49:31)
Yeah. Yeah.
Kat Green (49:33)
we’re walking through that, that kind of takes you through that sequence. give the, I give the command, I give it a solid five seconds. During that five seconds, I’m often thinking, so maybe the next week, I remember stickers don’t work. And so I’m in that moment going, okay.
What’s my if then? know, I’ll problem solve with parents, but instead we’re just doing it in our heads when we are the parent. And I’m thinking through what privileges come immediately next, or are there like bonus things they can do? It’s not like if you clean up, I’ll give you $5 cause that’s going to become untenable real quick. It would work, but it’s
Emma McAdam (50:06)
Yeah, yeah.
Kat Green (50:07)
probably not sustainable. So instead thinking what are things that come?
Immediately after this that are things he likes to do. And I could say if you don’t clean up, you won’t get a sticker. Like you can phrase it like that. There’s nothing science doesn’t show that’s going to ruin that. Like, no, it’s fine. But I typically will practice that positive just
Emma McAdam (50:28)
Mm.
Kat Green (50:28)
because as parents, we sometimes have less practice with that. But
Emma McAdam (50:32)
That’s a
Kat Green (50:32)
with my own kids all the time, right? If, if you don’t get your shoes on, you won’t push the garage door button or, but.
If you do, you will. the consequence is the same. It doesn’t matter as long as you’re using the overall principle of attaching something that maybe they already get to do, but it’s now contingent on them following the instruction at the developmentally appropriate level that they are. So that’s kind of walking all the way through.
Review the Steps for How to Get Your Kid to Listen to You
Emma McAdam (50:55)
Okay, okay, so big picture. Give them a transitional heads up. Get 1000 % of their attention. Give them a specific command. Hey, I need you to clean up the toys. Then, waiting five seconds. Then, giving them an if then. Hey, if you clean up the toys, you get a sticker. Then, they don’t clean up the toys. And you’re like, okay, maybe next time. Maybe next time you’ll get a sticker. Then, they melt down and you don’t, be like, no, no, no.
No, like you don’t change what the reward is. Okay, no, no. If you, I’ll give you two stickers if you clean up. Come on, come on, please. It’s really important that you clean up, buddy. Like, can’t you see you made this mess? It’s your job. None of that, right? None of that power struggle sticks strictly to like the sequence of if you do this, this is what happens. And then if they don’t do it, you wait five seconds, then they’re like, fine, fine, fine. You’re like, no, guess next time you’ll get a sticker and they’re like, fine, fine, fine. I’ll clean up. You’re like,
Maybe next time, right? You don’t give in on that last stop.
Kat Green (51:55)
Yeah, and part of it might depend, like, to be honest, part of it will depend on my tolerability. if I, like the five seconds, it’s the principle, but if I’ve got it mostly up, I will deliberately leave one more piece out,
Emma McAdam (52:08)
Yeah.
Kat Green (52:09)
right? And if at the five seconds, he’s like, fine, and comes over and puts it in, that’s a chance for him to rehearse doing the thing that I asked him to do. So,
Emma McAdam (52:17)
That’s right.
Kat Green (52:18)
versus if you feel like you’re being held hostage by this, fine, fine, fine. So I don’t, there’s not, there’s not a perfect way to deal with that switching at the last minute, as long as you’re holding to these principles where you don’t feel like you’re having to change what it was. so the biggest growth in if thens is just coming up with thens, because they’re different based on the kid, they’re different based on the context, right? If it’s bedtime versus in the car versus at home, I’ll have parents put sticky notes in different places in their house where they start writing things that work, right? That it’s like, okay, in the car.
They can bring a favorite toy, they can pick a radio station and we’ll play the, you know, 20 questions. Well, picking stuff that’s small, really that’s attention driven. And what that’s doing is helping reinforce this part of their brain that’s like, yeah, nailed it. Right. That’s what we want to, to build, but avoiding that feeling like you’re scrambling. And again, worst case scenario, if it doesn’t work, if it looks like it does already.
You just do the consequence, you norm it like it. it’s you physically have to go put them in the car, you’re already having to do that. But now there was learning that happened.
Emma McAdam (53:24)
Yeah.
Kat Green (53:25)
And in these iterations, time after time, you will start to see that shift. It just is a little bit slower. And this is really having to enforce the consequence if they did not do the thing. That’s where these other skills kind of come into play in that sequence.
But also you will be surprised at how much the waiting and the turning your spotlight on to anything that is compliance for kids that are youngish, sevenish, younger. I mean, that is gold to them. That’s what they care
Emma McAdam (53:55)
Yeah.
Kat Green (53:57)
about. so that’s where you will see a huge increase in compliance when you didn’t even go to the if then. Right. It’s like, we did the thing. And they still get like if it’s if the normal rule is when they clean up, they get a sticker.
They don’t have to have the if then to earn a sticker, right? It’s like, great job. With that said, sometimes you also have to jump straight to the if then if there’s, you know, a sense of urgency or harm or something, you know, if I can see the little brother gearing up, right? If you throw that toy, I will put them away. So you can also jump in. And the other thing is if it’s not time limited, I love when thens, right? Well, when that is put away, you can have your screen time for the day and then
Emma McAdam (54:37)
Yeah.
Kat Green (54:37)
you just walk away.
Emma McAdam (54:38)
Yeah.
Kat Green (54:39)
There’s no, like, it doesn’t, like, you don’t have to do anything else about it. And they
Emma McAdam (54:42)
Mmm.
Kat Green (54:42)
can tantrum as long as they want, but if it’s not time sensitive, when they say, my screens, right, if they’re older, I might say, soon as that’s cleaned up.
Emma McAdam (54:51)
Yeah. So,
Kat Green (54:53)
And then we’re gone.
Practical Examples of How to Get Your Kid to Listen to You
Emma McAdam (54:55)
That’s great. That’s great. So then like, can you give us some examples of like consequences for like
Kat Green (55:00)
Yeah.
Emma McAdam (55:01)
chores? Like, okay, you need to, you need to sweep the kitchen. That’s the chore. Every like we have a rotating chores. So every night after dinner, they all have a zone. do probably would take them six minutes to do their job.
Kat Green (55:12)
Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.
Emma McAdam (55:14)
And if they don’t hop up and do it, then what?
Kat Green (55:18)
So, I guess the first question I have is you tell me, like what, right now what happens if they don’t do their chore?
Emma McAdam (55:24)
Usually it’s like if you do your chore right now, I’ll do it with you. That’s usually like I’ll do it with you I’ll help you like dishes is the harder one So they always have a parent paired with dishes if you do your chore right now, I’ll help you But if you don’t get started on it, I’m gonna go do something else and then you’ll have to figure it out on your own and then I guess the next thing would be like when you’re done with your chore then you can go read you can go play outside You can do whatever and I guess at the very end it’s like if you you don’t do your chore at all today then like tomorrow you’d probably get two chores which means you wouldn’t have time for your books. Now this was my older kids right like my eight to eleven year
Kat Green (56:09)
Yeah, yeah.
Emma McAdam (56:09)
old like tomorrow you’re gonna you’re gonna have to spend more time helping around the house tomorrow you’ll get two chores tomorrow plus your
Kat Green (56:17)
Yeah.
Emma McAdam (56:18)
regular chore.
That may be a bit much, but yeah.
Kat Green (56:19)
So I think it’s, well, but you again, for older kids, may not. And you can kind of gauge, you know, your kids best, right? What they’re, and if we’re talking about two to six minute chores, it’s different than saying you’ll scrub the floor from house to body, even though they think, you know, they basically are, yeah, they’re like,
Emma McAdam (56:34)
It does feel like infinity, yes.
Kat Green (56:36)
I’m basically an indentured servant now. And it’s like, okay, whoa.
So it sounds like you’ve already thought through, mean, so you have a natural if then that is just kind of a rule that is if, all right, it’s time for chores. Anyone who gets started right now gets parent help. So that’s kind of.
Emma McAdam (56:51)
Yeah. Also, yeah, and also it’s like there’s no screens, no books, no Kindles until chores are done. So like dinner’s
Kat Green (56:57)
So that’s.
Emma McAdam (56:58)
over. You can’t do anything until your chores are done.
Kat Green (57:01)
So I think that’s a natural, it’s a win then.
Emma McAdam (57:03)
Yeah.
Kat Green (57:04)
So there’s kind of two pieces. If you do it now, I will help you. When your chore is done, you can have access to privileges. And I typically won’t have kids hold out for more than a day or two. They might, if they’re feeling pretty surly, that it’s like, well, forget it, I don’t want screens, I don’t want books, I don’t want this. Okay, they’re just gonna be bored all night.
Emma McAdam (57:20)
Yeah. Yeah.
Kat Green (57:23)
It’s not a harmful consequence for them. It’s like, okay,
Emma McAdam (57:25)
Right.
Kat Green (57:26)
and the next day,
The most important thing is that you’ve got your kind of matter of fact, non-escalated parent face on, right? Then after dinner the next day you can decide whether you reset, right? The natural consequence is they lost privileges last night. If it’s persistent, like you could also say, you have your chore from last night and tonight. I would try the other first, I would try kind
Emma McAdam (57:46)
Yeah.
Kat Green (57:47)
of having it reset first. And sometimes I will escalate like that. But the truth is, that’s not typically needed. one other caveat on if then so it’s important that you follow through that you’re consistent. All of us, especially for older kids have often said if thens that are completely absurd.
Emma McAdam (58:06)
Yeah.
Kat Green (58:06)
If you don’t do this, you’ll never play with your friends again. Or if you don’t, if you don’t get ready, we’ll leave you home. That’s exactly right. Okay,
Emma McAdam (58:09)
That’s right. You don’t get to come on our family vacation. Yeah. Yeah.
Kat Green (58:14)
when that happens, you can walk it back, like you will walk it back. But I wouldn’t
Emma McAdam (58:18)
You have to.
Kat Green (58:19)
try to deal with it in the moment. So when everyone’s melting, I will just take a beat and reset the if-then. So then come back and say, all right, if this doesn’t get done, you will lose your screen time tomorrow.
So just like if you find that absurd thing come out of your mouth or especially for kids, consequences that extend beyond a day, maybe two, it’s actually no more effective for the kid to lose their screens for a day as it is a week if it’s a daily privilege. having a sense like losing in the future isn’t likely from a neurological level to make them learn. It just punishes you in the future. You’re just punishing your future self.
Emma McAdam (58:57)
Yeah. That’s true. Yeah.
Kat Green (59:02)
And so it’s, it’s okay to walk it back, but I want you to take a break and reset it deliberately instead of sort of in the moment, either digging in or
Emma McAdam (59:11)
Yeah.
Kat Green (59:12)
saying, my gosh, I’m sorry. didn’t know that. it’s like just step out,
reset, come back.
Emma McAdam (59:17)
Okay, actually, yeah.
Kat Green (59:18)
Yeah.
Emma McAdam (59:19)
Can we try one more like set of if-thens? Like what would be some consequences? So like my kids do not like to get out the door on time,
Kat Green (59:28)
Mm-hmm.
Emma McAdam (59:29)
even if we have enough time to get it all done.
Kat Green (59:32)
Mm-hmm.
Emma McAdam (59:32)
So it’s like the last five minutes, I’m like, guys, I gotta be at work at eight.
You guys need to get on your bikes. Go get on your bikes. Get on your bikes. Get on your bike. Come on. Get on your bike. Get on your bike. Get your shoes on. Get on your bikes. Go, go, go. It would make all of us feel less stressed than me just pleading with you for 10 minutes to get out the door.
Kat Green (59:50)
Yeah, I mean, so what you’re describing is what might potentially become a standing if-then in the house, so like a house rule or something like that. So if it’s something that’s a frequent flyer, maybe it is just a known.
Parenting with Creative Rewards and Age-Appropriate Expectations
Kat Green
The difference is with a house rule, you’ll probably introduce it to them and say like, all right, here’s the deal. Here’s the standing if then your littles will still need it repeated more often. A couple of thoughts come to mind.
Emma McAdam (1:00:11)
We, it is a standing up then, every morning they have four things, they’re on the wall, they’re taped to
Kat Green (1:00:16)
Yeah.
Emma McAdam (1:00:16)
the wall in multiple places, you get up, you do your hair, you eat breakfast, you brush your teeth, right? And then out the door at eight. That’s like pasted on the wall.
Kat Green (1:00:23)
And what’s the consequence if they don’t?
Emma McAdam (1:00:27)
On weekdays, nothing, we just tell them to do it more. On weekends, like they literally, like they can’t play with friends, they can’t do screens. That’s the only time we have screens. So it’s like they,
Kat Green (1:00:34)
Right. Yeah.
Emma McAdam (1:00:37)
Like, if you wanna have screens, That’s a win then, it’s fine. but then sometimes they don’t, then I get anxious, but it’s like 10 o’clock and they haven’t done their chore and I’m like, come on, just get it done.
Kat Green (1:00:46)
So a couple of things come to mind and it’s across an age span.
Right. So I’ll give some of these examples and then obviously you can apply them based on their developmental stage, So if you were, if it was getting out the door in the car, some common ones are getting to take, a special toy or having a mad libs in the car that they fill out as they go or something that’s activity based or attention based, something that they only get to do in the car when they’re out the door on time. as I think about getting on bikes, it’s going to be harder to find things that are as immediate, right?
Emma McAdam (1:01:18)
even having this conversation, they love it when I walk them to school. School’s like four blocks, three blocks, right?
Kat Green (1:01:24)
Mm-hmm.
Emma McAdam (1:01:24)
They love it when I walk to school. So if I need to be at work at eight and I say, I can walk you to school if we leave at 7:55, then I will go with you. All my kids are like, mom, my 11 year old, mom, take me to school. Or like Ryan will buzz him on his scooter like they’ll ride on his scooter with him. They love that. So maybe we do like 7:55 we’ll go with you
Kat Green (1:01:46)
Yeah, like I would have just a natural effect then that says, okay, if you’re ready by then we’ll go with you. Then you just have to think through what if they’re not so are there two parents available where or if they’re old enough, can you actually leave them and then they have to catch up. So thinking through those making sure it’s you have that ahead of time because otherwise in the moment you’ll be like, what do do with this one? Like they weren’t ready. Do we leave them? So
Emma McAdam (1:02:09)
Yeah.
Kat Green (1:02:09)
I love that saying. The nice thing is it’s kind of a joint sibling goal. So there might be some encouragement from each other if they want to walk with mom. So
Emma McAdam (1:02:17)
Yeah. Yeah.
Kat Green (1:02:19)
I love that using that as an if then other things that they could earn right after school, right? you could certainly do something like a token system that they’re earning towards like, Hey, then you put a sticker on the chart or you do the marble in jar or something like that. And they’re earning towards something they want to do. but it could also be if there’s things they really like, especially that are parent attention focused, right? Then everyone who’s ready by eight and on their bike, right? When you get home from school, we do a two minute mom time, right? Or we do slips on, oh my gosh, they would love that so much. Or
Emma McAdam (1:02:49)
I will do flips with you on the tramp despite my aversions to this. Yeah.
Kat Green (1:02:54)
we’ll do two minutes of you telling me, I mean, I don’t say it in this many words, but two minutes of you telling me about the thing I really don’t care about, but you really do care about, right? The video game or the book or the thing that you’re just like,
Emma McAdam (1:03:02)
That’s right. Yeah. Babel
Kat Green (1:03:05)
I actually hate talking
Emma McAdam (1:03:05)
Haven.
Kat Green (1:03:06)
about it, but instead it’s like two minute download. it’s a great way to connect that way. you, can also think through small attention based. You, could also have a consequence to say like, Hey, if you’re not out there by eight, you have an extra tour after school. I know it’s a real bummer, but.
Emma McAdam (1:03:20)
Yeah, because mommy lost, mom lost, I lost time at work, it was stressful for me, I need you to help me with something when you get home. If you’re late, you’ve got to help me with something.
Kat Green (1:03:30)
I think you can have that conversation or not. Right? And it’s
Emma McAdam (1:03:32)
Yeah, that’s right. We don’t need to explain it to them. That’s a good point. Like
Kat Green (1:03:35)
Like they’re responsible for getting out the door at eight. And
Emma McAdam (1:03:38)
Yeah.
Kat Green (1:03:39)
if they don’t, there’s a chore after school. So with your older, I think you could introduce that logic, but I would only do it once and in a family setting of just, Hey, this is what we’re going to do. And then I wouldn’t bring it up or talk about it when you’re enforcing or when it comes up in the moment.
Emma McAdam (1:03:53)
Okay, yeah, in the moment. That makes sense. I mean, I do want in general, I want my kids to understand that we don’t have arbitrary rules, that we’re a unit, we care about each other,
Kat Green (1:04:00)
Yes.
Emma McAdam (1:04:00)
we’re working together to make our home a nice place, we’re working together
Kat Green (1:04:03)
Mm-hmm.
Emma McAdam (1:04:04)
like I’m doing this for you, you’re doing this for me, but that you’re right that the place for that is not in the moment. Not in the moment of correction.
Kat Green (1:04:12)
It may also be like your younger kids may not have the developmental skills to follow that whole conversation you just had. it may be, well,
Emma McAdam (1:04:19)
And I shouldn’t be putting that responsibility in them for like, my
Kat Green (1:04:21)
if I went to your home and asked your kids, what are different ways you can help mom and dad? I bet they would come up with some of those. And so that tells me you’re teaching them. Like
Emma McAdam (1:04:28)
Okay.
Kat Green (1:04:29)
it tells me they know it’s not a problem with not understanding the family value. If they’re not getting out the door at eight o’clock in the morning, they’re likely not like, well, I don’t care about the family and contributing. I
Emma McAdam (1:04:38)
Yeah,
Kat Green (1:04:39)
think one of the risks of over-emphasizing the rationale is we can sometimes misattribute intentionality, right? Or we see their behavior as a lack of like contributing
Emma McAdam (1:04:50)
Yeah, yeah.
Kat Green (1:04:51)
to that. And the truth is it’s a thousand percent not in their brain. At eight o’clock in the morning, they’re like, but I’m doing Legos. And I think that’s, think where I like introducing it. And then as they get older, they will be able to understand more of that concept. I think as teens, they can now understand some of that one-to-one, like my time and your time. But as kids, that is not the reason they’re not getting out the door. All right.
Emma McAdam (1:05:15)
Okay. They need it to be more concrete and it’s almost unfair to them to ask them to comprehend these like bigger abstract concepts.
Kat Green (1:05:22)
I think you can sit like I, you throw it out there but it’s not it’s not there’s no pressure for them to understand the full picture right now and as they get older they will.
Parents Need Gentle Parenting: Giving Ourselves Grace
Emma McAdam (1:05:31)
Yeah, and I think that is how like with my oldest I contributed a lot to her anxiety was by trying to like explain to her why this is so important and she’s like I just wanted to play Barbies mom like You making me feel really guilty like really guilty and like guilt ripping her almost by being like can’t you understand how you’re affecting me and all she needed was like if if you stop playing Barbies now, then you’ll get a sticker. Okay, mom
Kat Green (1:05:57)
But here’s the thing, yes, kids with different temperaments may need a shift because of the way that their brain works, but all of us come to parenting with our own experience of parenting, right? And so a lot of people come into this going, it’s going to be different than it was for me, but we don’t necessarily know how. And then every kid is different—it’s really rude. You figure one thing out with one, and then you’re like, nope, nope, that doesn’t work.
Emma McAdam (1:06:20)
Yeah.
Kat Green (1:06:22)
I think also giving yourself a lot of grace and recognizing our need to over explain and be gentle and instill values is because you care. It’s like I a thousand times prefer working with parents who want to figure out how to kind of help their kids feel more effective, help reduce overall tension, but they’re very invested and they really want their kid to feel good all the time.
That’s much more flexible than a parent who they wouldn’t come into me, but who just is like, I don’t care. don’t, I have no interest in what they do. Granted, there are some times that you can love your children and not want to spend time with them. That’s not what I’m talking about. Right. But
Emma McAdam (1:06:59)
Sure, sure,
Kat Green (1:07:00)
just like fundamentally be like, I don’t care. Like this is over, over explaining. I did like, that’s just a sign that you care about them and it’s warmth and it can be really, really protective. And we just have to shape a little bit to fit their brain.
Emma McAdam (1:07:13)
Yeah, that’s so encouraging. Thank you so much for
Kat Green (1:07:16)
Yes.
Emma McAdam (1:07:16)
all your deep thoughts. have anything I’ve missed? Any last thing you want parents to know?
Kat Green (1:07:20)
just that they’re doing a good job, like give themselves credit. if it doesn’t match, you know what they’re seeing other people do, it’s because kids don’t match other kids. like there’s kids are incredibly resilient. They’re incredibly flexible. We all are like, wow, that didn’t work. And the cool thing is we’ve got plenty of data that shows kids are resilient and they’ll figure out new ways to interact if your kid is really challenging, if things aren’t working, there are people, There are therapists and psychologists this is what they do is to help kind of provide parent focused support for big emotions.
Evidence-Based Parenting Resources
Emma McAdam (1:07:56)
Can you point people in the right direction? Because I do feel like when I’ve sought therapy for my kids, I’ve had a couple experiences where the therapist is very warm, very engaging, very caring, and they do a lot of play therapy, but they aren’t necessarily directive in guiding me toward the skills that have made such a big difference for me. So how can someone find a therapist or a psychologist or an education system that’s gonna help them. What do you like? What do you recommend?
Kat Green (1:08:28)
Yeah, I actually have a YouTube video about this that’s probably pretty boring.
Emma McAdam (1:08:32)
good. Great.
Kat Green (1:08:34)
But it’s like, you know, my weird nerdy passion area is finding evidence based care. And I think what’s challenging is therapy that works is not always like cool and flashy and sexy and stuff like it’s it’s likely not something that was just discovered. It’s
Emma McAdam (1:08:50)
Yeah.
Kat Green (1:08:50)
not going to be like we now know something we never knew before.
It’s not going to make 100 % guarantees like what you are describing, support for parents is going to be parent focused. So a lot of individual talk therapy, play therapy, one-on-one therapy with kids is considered supportive therapy and there’s a place for it, but it typically is not going to result in behavior change. And
Emma McAdam (1:09:14)
Yeah.
Kat Green (1:09:14)
so you’re looking for something, there’s the… either behavior parent training or parent management training, PMT, that is like directly supporting, it comes in individual, there’s group-based, there’s all sorts of really good methods for finding that. But I think asking explicitly, approach do you use to support parents?
Emma McAdam (1:09:34)
Mm-hmm.
Kat Green (1:09:34)
What is the evidence to support it? Also, if you’re in a therapy experience, you should know what the treatment goals are and
Emma McAdam (1:09:42)
Yeah.
Kat Green (1:09:42)
how they’re measuring change. Right? So to say, how do I know if this is getting better? Especially with kids, right? You’ll have some weeks that you’re like, this week was really atrocious, but I feel like it’s still getting better. Right? Like finding out how, how do we know it’s getting better? So those are kind of things that evidence-based clinicians should be able to answer. And if they can’t, I’ve got some concerns. Yeah.
Emma McAdam (1:10:05)
Yeah, there should be markers.
Kat Green (1:10:08)
But I think in general, looking specific to this question, looking for PMT approaches, if it’s more in the anxiety realm, you’ll often see a mix of kind PMT or family-based CBT for
Emma McAdam (1:10:21)
Yeah.
Kat Green (1:10:22)
kids. There should be a strong kind of parent component that’s supporting that. Because it’s telling kids what to do, having a therapist tell them what to do. A lot of people are like, think if someone else tells them what to do. And I’m like, here’s the thing. They know what to do. They just can’t do it.
Emma McAdam (1:10:37)
Yeah, yeah.
Kat Green (1:10:39)
It’s not gonna, you’re not gonna see a lot of change in that one-on-one talk therapy if there isn’t a lot of parent support. And the younger they get, there’s likely gonna be no change, right? It really is all
Emma McAdam (1:10:49)
That’s right.
Kat Green (1:10:49)
parent focused.
Emma McAdam (1:10:51)
Yeah, I feel like, if you want to help your kid, get support for yourself, that’s gonna teach you
Kat Green (1:10:56)
Yeah.
Emma McAdam (1:10:57)
evidence-based skills that will help you be a better parent cause we interact with our kids like 160 hours a week and the therapist can interact with our kids like one hour, 40 minutes a week.
Yes, in the cases of trauma and other situations, a kid can use someone to talk to, like one of my kids goes to therapy, but
Kat Green (1:11:12)
Yes.
Emma McAdam (1:11:13)
in conjunction with us seeing this therapist as a couple and getting parenting support.
Kat Green (1:11:19)
Well, and also keeping in mind, one of the coolest things about evidence-based therapy is most of the time, especially for kids, it’s time limited. You’re not signing up for forever therapy. I might meet for eight sessions, right? For
Emma McAdam (1:11:27)
Yeah. Yes. Yes.
Kat Green (1:11:31)
my littles, I might meet for six sessions with parents, right?
Emma McAdam (1:11:33)
Yes!
Kat Green (1:11:34)
You’re looking for something focused
Emma McAdam (1:11:36)
That’s awesome. Okay, well, we will put those links in the show notes, links in the description. Dr. Kat thank you so much for giving us your time today. Really, really appreciate
Kat Green (1:11:42)
Yeah, of course. You said.
Emma McAdam (1:11:44)
it. And yeah, thank you.

